My first J&W book was Jeeves in the Morning, which has Jeeves behaving in a very romantic fashion. Wooster's friend even tells him that Jeeves, when the lovebirds reconciled in the garden, was looking distinctively teary-eyed. Jeeves says stuff to Wooster about how his heart melts when he sees a rainbow. Now that is a romantic, IMHO.

I like your guilt-fic idea. Simple, to the point, and gets us where we want to go.

Being sappy is the way to go. *g*